The University of Calgary Gauntlet®
  2008-09-18
(NOTE: Archived content:
Current issue here)

[image]
Previous Issues

News
Campus food bank use falling
Event helps homeless in Calgary get ID and shelter
Campuses thirsty for water across Canada
Bob Page rules the environmental world
Former Calgarian helps kids in Nicaragua
Canadian stranded in Guantanamo Bay
Wireless access expands outside
News for the unnewsed: Economy in crisis

Opinions
Insane invasion
Letter: A bunch of cheap bastards
Letter: Food for thought
Palin and gender
Where's the valve-less water waste preventer?
Too much to take
A floppy sickness
A crusty ass carbon tax
Palin and the new American leadership
Slammin' elements
Dictating culture to the masses
Sex sells
Silencing the critics
SU View: SU offers free weekly events and entertainment

Sports
Fumbles, flags and follies, oh my!
Women's soccer squad still searching for first win
Optimism the key for successful field hockey season
Sportspinions: Parity in football this fall is freakin' fun
Men's hockey team prepares for start of season
Dinos soccer team learns to deal with growing pains

Entertainment
Captured motion
Looking at the life of the sasquatch
Broken Contender breaks in young filmmaker
MBF is totally your super awesome best friend
Bringing the broodiness
Some joke about tumours
Theatre and dance kick off the season in September
Sloan's music is action packed
TV is awesome, guys
Spun: Mother Mother
Spun: Natalie Cole
Spun: Bison B.C.
Spun: Blind Melon




  Column: Pidgeon Talk
Palin and the new American leadership





[Print] Print this story

ADVERTISMENT

ADVERTISMENT

Pidgeon Talk:
OPINIONS Entitlement run amok in citizenship guide
OPINIONS Jay-Z, the Stampede and tuition hikes
OPINIONS An absentee Canadian? In defence of Ignatieff
OPINIONS Where have all the "great authors" gone?
OPINIONS Of mallards and millionaires

W e're dedicated to the proposition that all people are created equal and endowed by our creator with inalienable rights. No country ever had a greater cause than that.

- John McCain

"Al-Qaeda terrorists still plan to inflict catastrophic harm on America and he [Obama] is worried that someone won't read them their rights."

- Sarah Palin

These two obviously contradictory statements by the Republican presidential ticket were made within 24 hours of one another at the party's convention two weeks ago. The glaring inconsistency wasn't scrutinized, though, and became lost in the intellectual wasteland of American presidential politics-- where something so minor as the treatment of human beings couldn't possibly attract the attention of the vultures. Yet, this is one of the most important issues the campaign could possibly be about.

In his address to the Democratic National Convention the week prior, President Bill Clinton stated that there were two issues of paramount importance in this election: "to rebuild the American dream and restore American leadership in the world." In order to do so, the U.S. must assert not only its military and cultural leadership, but its moral as well. Clearly, how the country chooses to treat its prisoners has tremendous implications for this.

It is interesting to note that Palin, making such a comment-- which suggests she doesn't have too much concern for how prisoners are treated-- does so while on the same ballot as the only Republican candidate who consistently rejected the use of torture throughout the primaries. That said, this curiosity is not the heart of the issue. Rather, the point that McCain made in his speech is. Disregarding the rights of perceived enemies erodes the philosophic foundation upon which the U.S. is erected. Surely there can be no clearer and more alarming indication that things have gone terribly wrong with the U.S. political situation than the fact that such a statement-- the direct antithesis of the American ideal-- can find its way into a vice-presidential candidate's speech.

In order for the U.S. to reassert itself as a respected world leader, it must go back to its beginning and resurrect its ideals.

Share this story: del.icio.us digg Fark NewsVine Reddit YahooMyWeb


Reader Comments:

 Add your comment or send a letter to the editor

Posted: 2008-09-19 09:54:57
#1 - The sad thing is that this lady from the north lies so much that for her the difference between lies and truth are a gray mass of nothingness. Those of us who are not lucky to be citizens of your great country, are scared of the prospect that another less than honest, not well educated, poor excuse of a leader is going to continue the damage done to your country and the whole world. God Save us and God Bless America.


–peter komlos, retired


Posted: 2008-09-19 09:59:47
#2 - McCain didn't specify what those rights are. They probably include freedom from tyranny, but not the freedom to inflict tyranny, so I don't see the statements as being in conflict at all.
When America starts accepting that one of those rights is the right to not be "American", then their stature on the world stage might stop shrivelling. I doubt they have that kind of integrity.


–rufus, engineering


Posted: 2008-09-19 13:57:40
#3 - Cam Cotton-O'Brien writes

" . . . President Bill Clinton stated that . . . "

I've got news for you Cam. You might want to look into who is presently President of the U.S. before engaging in political commentary


–John Paul, PhD Student


Posted: 2008-09-19 14:17:53
#4 - According to Wikipedia: much like how all former Prime Ministers of Canada retain the title of "The Right Honourable," all former United States Presidents retain the title of President into perpetuity.


–Ryan Pike


 Views expressed are those of the posters and do not necessarily reflect that of the Gauntlet.

ADVERTISMENT

ADVERTISMENT

RSS icon RSS Feeds:
[ Main - News - Opinions - Entertainment - Sports ]
Volunteer at the Gauntlet®
.