The University of Calgary Gauntlet®
  2008-10-02
(NOTE: Archived content:
Current issue here)

[image]
Previous Issues

News
New chair tackles domestic violence
Speaker denounces nuclear dangers
No one left to point students in the right direction
From Wall Street to Main Street
Bees with disease bring farmers to their knees
CJSW takes another baby step towards new crib
Speaker gives university education to those in need
Student finds smallest dino in North America
News for the unnewsed
Housing debate continues, slowly

Opinions
HPV freakout
Letter: affordable housing blues
Letter: a call to abandon ship
Mind fights: The abolition of arts funding
Promoting promiscuity?
Nuclear energy's powerful questions
The Beatles are overrated
W's terrible legacy
A country's degradation
People who shouldn't nap:
The benefit of teach-o-nauts
With Glowing Hearts we trademark thee
The trouble of being Kanye
The incorrect response to HPV: jeopardizing the health of young girls
SU View

Sports
CIS CANADA WEST MEN'S HOCKEY PREVIEW 2008-09
Women soccersaurs get their roar back
Dino volleysaurs tourney champs
Nill lands new recruit
Dinos golf teams repeat as ACAC champions in Red Deer
Our football is better than your football
Dinos deliver in biggest game to date
UBC netminder fools Dinos once, Dinos get last laugh
First win feels good for field hockeyers

Entertainment
Blindness provides insight into humanity
Religion + ridiculous = preachy doc
Blind Melon is more than just the bee girl
The Horrorpops do the ol' switcheroo
Nick and Norah mixes a love story with sketched indie title font
The numbers balance out for 3
Funk singer Slim Twig has the skinny on success
October music is pretty good
Movie adaptation takes Palahniuk's words too literally
Spun: Gym Class Heroes
Spun: Underoath
Spun: Jarvis Church
Spun: The Famines




  Our football is better than your football
American college football should have a playoff system similar to the Canadian system




[Print] Print this story

ADVERTISMENT

ADVERTISMENT

Sportspinions
SPORTSCFL star to join Canadian Bobsled team
ENTERTAINMENTThe Fray
SPORTSWhen coaches are negligent
SPORTSDefining elite, and also using the word
SPORTSYou gotta fight for your right to . . . fight

There is a remarkable difference in the playoff structures of Canadian and American university/college football. The American system is not a fair judge of the best team in the nation.

In Canada, for a team to be crowned the Vanier Cup Champions, they must qualify for playoffs in their region, go through elimination rounds and then play in a championship game.

This is a fair system and can correctly determine the proper national champion because it forces the best teams to play each other.

Like the States, Canada does rank their teams and this determines playoff seeding, but the teams still have to win every game.

It forces teams to play their best football against the best teams in the nations giving the top and lowest ranked team's equal chance at success.

In fact, last year the top ranked Laval football team did not even make the Vanier Cup final, as the University of Manitoba Bisons won the cup.

In the States, college teams do not have a playoff system in place. Rather, each week in the season the media, coaches and a computer rank the teams.

At the end of the season, the top two teams play for the national championship. This is not an adequate system for determining a national champion. It is flawed in many ways.

A team losing in the first several weeks of the season is almost completely written out of the championship game.

University of Southern California is a prime example this year. They won their first two games against high ranked opponents (Ohio State and Virginia), outscoring the two 87-10. The third game against an unranked opponent (Oregon State) they lost 27-21, dropping them from first to ninth in the polls.

This almost eliminates USC from playing in the national championship this year. The polls also take the severity of the schedule into play. It is harder for exceptional teams to get up for the small easy games and ultimately they do worse.

Several other top-five teams also lost this weekend, dropping them out of contention for the championship and allowing possibly less talented teams who happen to have a good week to rise in the polls and play in the national championship. Last year Hawaii went undefeated, playing a fairly tough schedule and was excluded from the national championship game, another flaw in the system. The top teams in the States should be given a fair chance to prove their worth.

Every team can have one bad week and this should not hurt them later in the season.

The American system needs to change so that a proper national champion can be crowned.

Let the teams decide who is best by adopting a playoff system.

The United States need to look to the north and adopt the Canadian system for crowning a champion.

Share this story: del.icio.us digg Fark NewsVine Reddit YahooMyWeb


Reader Comments:

 Add your comment or send a letter to the editor

No comments found. Be the first!

 Views expressed are those of the posters and do not necessarily reflect that of the Gauntlet.

ADVERTISMENT

ADVERTISMENT

RSS icon RSS Feeds:
[ Main - News - Opinions - Entertainment - Sports ]
Volunteer at the Gauntlet®
.