The University of Calgary Gauntlet®
  2009-11-12
(NOTE: Archived content:
Current issue here)

[image]
Previous Issues

News
U of C given biggest gift in its history
Two biomedical engineering research centres to open on campus
U of C's interim president named
CJSW moving, for real this time
Love of books leads prof to India and back
Moustaches matter in Movember
Texting and transit

Opinions
Editorial: Rupert Murdoch hates the Internet
The hidden cost of coffee
The monarchy has to go
Administration and trust at the U of C
Online Exclusive: Euthanasia bill has my vote

Sports
Dinos face Huskies for Hardy Cup
All-star nods
Sports briefs: runners head east for CIS championships
Early morning splashing
Moving on up

Entertainment
Ground Zero Theatre ain't selling out
Amreeka details the trials and tribulations of a post-9/11 world
Dinosaur Jr. roar back from extinction
A champion of experimentalism




  Column: Fighting Words
The monarchy has to go
Why reform to Canada's head of state is necessary




[Print] Print this story
 (Click for larger image.)

Credit: Jen Grond / the Gauntlet  


ADVERTISMENT

ADVERTISMENT

Fighting Words:
OPINIONS Our national anthem needs revision
OPINIONS Baby Isaiah should be allowed to die
OPINIONS Can the games solve Canada's weight problem?
OPINIONS Stop giving tax breaks to religious groups
OPINIONS On Haiti, God, and the case for aid

If you ask Canadians who Canada's head of state is three out of four people will get it wrong. According to a poll taken last year, 50 per cent thought it was Steven Harper and one-third thought it was Michaƫlle Jean, the governor general. Neither are correct, of course -- Canada's head of state is Queen Elizabeth II.

In case you didn't know that fact yourself, don't worry. In October, the website for the governor general stated that Jean was Canada's head of state: a mistake that underscores the lack of understanding Canadians have about their government, including those within it. The Queen infrequently visits, and is even less likely to be seen representing Canada abroad. But this past week the heir to the throne, Prince Charles, has been touring Canada in what some are calling a move to introduce himself as the future king.

It won't be long before Charles inherits the throne, but before he's welcomed with open arms, Canadians should consider a different choice: abolishing the monarchy in Canada altogether. The head of state is, among other things, the representative of a country to the rest of the world. The core of democracy is that citizens should choose who that representative is. Presently, our representation is forced upon us by the inheritance system of the British crown. The Queen never represents us abroad -- that role is left for the governor general, who is also not elected, but appointed by the prime minister. It's an insult that Canadians are robbed of this choice, and having a more local representative does nothing to soften the blow.

Canadians rightly hold equality of opportunity as a value. Every citizen, regardless of sex, race and religious affiliation, should be allowed to run for office. If the head of state is to successfully represent Canada abroad, a minimum requirement is residency in Canada. The present head of state fails to meet that criterion, of course. Discrimination gets no worse than when the head of state must also be the Supreme Governor of the Church of England. This rules out all believers who are not Protestant and all non-believers, and is a good example of a bad tradition that should no longer be endorsed.

Many argue that the queen does an adequate job as Canada's head of state, and in any case too much work would be required to amend what's essentially a symbolic position. The important point is that it only matters in passing how well the monarch is doing as our head of state. Assessing qualifications before assessing the validity of acquiring the position is, so to speak, putting the victory before the vote. Regardless of the job performed, it is first crucial that decision is left to Canadians. Representation has to be a choice; a system of inherited rights such as the monarchy is undemocratic and conflicts with Canadian values.

Reforming the position of head of state in Canada will be no small matter. Unique among constitutional reform, amending the head of state requires the unanimous consent of all federal and provincial legislatures. A number of polls suggest that despite the legal difficulties, Canadians support abolishing a foreign sovereign as our head of state, but the process will be arduous and lengthy. Much discussion will be necessary among Canadians to decide the type of republic best suited for our country, as many different forms exist and each one will shape Canada in a variety of ways.

Most importantly, the result will be one which is not forced upon Canadians, but is instead made by its citizens. A number of other Commonwealth countries have achieved this goal and it is past time that Canada did as well.

Share this story: del.icio.us digg Fark NewsVine Reddit YahooMyWeb


Reader Comments:

 Add your comment or send a letter to the editor

Posted: 2009-11-16 09:24:10
#1 - Why reform it? Just eliminate the position and the Governor General position. No need for either.


–GM


Posted: 2009-11-16 14:19:42
#2 - I used reform in the loose sense, meaning change, adapt, or amend. A possible solution would be the one you suggest; eliminating the position would solve many of the problems that plague it presently. I think that there is a purpose to the head of state, though, so eliminating the role altogether would be ill-advised. Rather, the position could be dissolved but the responsibilities handed over to another, such as the prime minister.


Eric Mathison, Writer


Posted: 2009-11-18 00:56:31
#3 - When we call the GG & Ontario LG Onley the staff pretend they're only there for Pomp & Ceremony & when he come to Town he was used for Photo ops by elected breaking down the Colonial democratic system set up, imperfect as it is, to lessen the 1st & 2nd readings for the public to be involved with the time period of somber 2nd thought etc.

www.topix.com/forum/ca/halton-hills-on-georgetown/TQGI9A3OEBS1REB7A


–Canadians Coast to Coast


 Views expressed are those of the posters and do not necessarily reflect that of the Gauntlet.

ADVERTISMENT

ADVERTISMENT

RSS icon RSS Feeds:
[ Main - News - Opinions - Entertainment - Sports ]
Volunteer at the Gauntlet®
.