The University of Calgary Gauntlet®
  2004-12-09
(NOTE: Archived content:
Current issue here)

[image]
Previous Issues

News
Equal funding?
U of A gets three times U of C's award money
He's the one they call Dr. Feelgood
Ceremony remembers slain women
November Campus Security report
COMS 363 troubles
Contining Educatoin get you their
U of C not sharing in MRC's bonus problems
Fall 2004 in Review
SU mid-term reviews
SU Review: President
SU Review: VP Academic
SU Review: VP External
SU Review: VP Events
SU Review: VP Op-Fi

Opinions
Seņor Winter
Expected Disappointment
Green Party doesn't steal
Hardened: an awkward juxtaposition
The power structure textbooks forgot
A shout out to the West's great minds
Celebrate the mathemagical world
No place for Blue
Reflections on Dec 6, 2004

Sports
Hockeysaurs de-feather Thunderbirds
Two much needed wins for volleysaurs
Basketballers make narrow escape
National nod for trackster
Report Card: Football
Report Card: Women's Soccer
Report Card: Men's Soccer
Report Card: Field Hockey
Cross Country

Entertainment
Concert Review: James Brown breaches 5th dimensional space to funk up Calgary
Behold the corpse of radio
Music Interview: RantMusic not a bunch of celtics
Music Interview: Dance to The Music
Theatre Review: Mee'sa needs'a see Mesa, mista
Theatre Preview: Ivanka laughs so hard she tinkles
Dance Preview: The Nutcracker hits the ice--ballet stylee
Movie Review: The Hebrew Hammer ain't no schmuck
Spun: Ludacris
Spun: Greg Davis
Spun: Q And Not U
Spun: The Music
Theatre Review: ATP's Pinocchio a magical delight

Features
Sexual Secrets 101: The World of Toys


AP
A contest of skill and judgement
How to get away with reviewing a dictionary

  [image] A shout out to the West's great minds





[Print] Print this story
 (Click for larger image.)

ADVERTISMENT

ADVERTISMENT

"I became aware, as early as my college days, that no opinion, however absurd and incredible can be imagined, that has not been held by one of the philosophers."

--Rene "solipsist extraordinaire" Descartes



Tell me I'm not the only one.

Tell me I'm not the first to have finished reading Descartes' Discourse on Method and reflexively gagged at the self-satisfied banality of a philosophy iterated thousands of times every day by angst-ridden teenage solipsists in black-wallpapered bedrooms across North America. Tell me I'm not the first to have learned about countless dead Greek, French and German thinkers and screamed, "These ideas don't belong to these assholes damn it. They're mine too!"

It's been said we live in a society constructed as a footnote to the biggest, most obnoxious Greek of them all. A pompous, ponderous erudite whose social predictions fell flat within the lifetime of his most famous pupil whose prize student turned out to be one of the greatest butchers of human history. I want to know that I'm not the only one who extends a vigorous middle finger to Plato and every ivory tower proclamation he made and know that he's no more responsible for my mind than the cut out pictures of Britney Spears on my sister's bedroom walls.

In an era where referential laziness can be called post-modernism, where outright parroting can be called homage, I want to know that the ideas pounding through my skull are as much mine as any Elizabethan playwright's.

Communications theorist Kenneth Burke imagined society as a drawn-out debate in a dank pub, with every human arriving mid-debate, listening and finally engaging without ever really knowing where it all began, leaving without having finished. While it may be true and the vocabulary of our intellect is deter-mined by the mutterings of long-dead pub patrons, I want to know that I owe no greater debt to the self-proclaimed intellectual elite than I do to the grammatical conventions that tie my sentences together and that, moreover, I can break wit' 'em whenever I dang well please.

Certain ideas have resonance; there's simply no denying it. Humanity will always be fascinated with the nature of nature, metaphysical conceits and, narcissists that we are, ourselves. We'll write about star-crossed lovers and we'll clamour for base, vulgar entertainment. For myself, I don't want to owe any debt to a culture of philosophical elitism whose followers need to place my thoughts in the context of one great historical footnote. I'm living in a world so full of new information and innovative art that I'm struggling to keep up as it is.

I'm not the only one, am I?

A list of "screw you" shout-outs to famous historical minds:

Plato--May you be trapped in a room of shadows for all eternity.

Socrates--If I had a penny for every vacuous, would-be intellectual who opened with the phrase "The only thing I know is that I know nothing," I'd be left with a heaping bag full of coins I would use to club you to death, hurting a hell of a lot more than hemlock did.

Johann Wolfgang von Goethe--Faust. It took you 25 years to write a series of disconnected episodes with a pat, deus ex machina ending? I despise you.

John Milton--Epic simile is just a literary way of saying too much damned description. Kudos for your description of the Devil and his angels, a heartfelt obscenity for the subsequent 11 books.

Rene Descartes--The reason you could conceive of a Perfect Being is because of your Christian upbringing. It's just that simple you Cartesian fop.

Henry David Thoreau--Walden was arrogant, poorly written, and you were within walking distance of a town you ivy league wanker.

Every single rationalist philosopher ex-pounding on their social transcendence--You can't just apply scientific laws to society and hope to gleam objectivity. Shut up. Seriously, just shut the hell up.

What's that? I can't hear you through six feet of dirt.

Share this story: del.icio.us digg Fark NewsVine Reddit YahooMyWeb


Reader Comments:

 Add your comment or send a letter to the editor

Posted: 2004-12-10 04:34:38
#1 - A phenomenal article! A creative piece with a comedic tone. It was refreshing to hear some candour regarding the great minds we are forced to worship in our university studies. I particularly enjoyed "Cartesian Fop".

Adam


–Adam Ramsay


Posted: 2004-12-10 12:46:15
#2 - This is an excellent article. Jeff is consistently the best opinions writer at the Gauntlet (present company excepted of course Adam). I hope he writes more often as his sense of irony (ridiculing philosophers while using them as the basis of his article) is great. :)


–Anonymous Coward


Posted: 2004-12-10 14:05:29
#3 - This is only the second opinions article Jeff has written for the Gauntlet, with the previous being penned two and a half years ago. How does this one very good piece make him consistently the best opinions writer in the paper?
Good piece though, Jeff. Please continue sticking it to the people who helped sculpt the shape of our society.


–dale, news ed.


Posted: 2004-12-11 04:24:39
#4 - This is either the work of a genius or a complete madman...and knowing Mr. Kubik, it has to be the former mixed with a bit of the latter. But it does takes a genius-cum-madman to take on da Man, man. I tip my hat to him.

However, I'm surprised none of the defenders of the establishment have opened their mouths to defend those wankers yet....hmmm, wonder why?


–John Leung Chung-Yin, Contributor, duh


 Views expressed are those of the posters and do not necessarily reflect that of the Gauntlet.

ADVERTISMENT

ADVERTISMENT

RSS icon RSS Feeds:
[ Main - News - Opinions - Entertainment - Sports ]
Volunteer at the Gauntlet®
.