Centrism is killing the left

Centrism is killing the left
Graphic by Jasmine Keller

Liberalism is a political philosophy that has centred on rights as a pillar since its inception. 

Social-democratic, liberal, and generally progressive political leaders are, arguably, some of the most memorable and admirable figures throughout history. 

Think Nelson Mandela, Martin Luther King Jr and Eleanor Roosevelt. 

Think Emmeline Pankhurst, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sirimavo Bandaranaike. 

Think Tommy Douglas, Harvey Milk and Jacinda Ardern. 

These figures are memorable. They, among certainly many others, helped in redefining what governments could and should do for their people. Their legacies include that of challenging embedded inequitable institutions, inequalities and general rights advocacy. Despite considerations of popularity or general establishment-based approval, these figures understood that progress often does require challenging the status quo. 

Today, I look at the contemporary left politicians and political movements in North America, and I find myself wondering: where has the ambition gone? 

In recent years, it seems as though the political left has become overly concerned with appearing reasonable to the political right. In this mission, their core values have been lost. When did winning over conservative voters become more important than inspiring the people who already believe in progressive politics? 

What is the point of even having a political left if it is so often virtually indistinguishable from major right-wing values? 

I believe that the left has become so afraid of losing the centre that it has largely lost itself. 

Centrism in its current application is becoming one of the left’s primary focuses amd subsequently one of their greatest obstacles. Progressive policies do not need to be radical necessarily, but they do need to be distinguishable from those of the right. 

This constant pursuit of middle ground is nice in theory, but has contributed to an environment in which any meaningful change is sacrificed for the sake of perceived electability.

Canada’s current Liberal government supplies us with an example of this phenomenon. 

Prime Minister Mark Carney’s political identity has been heavily associated with economic competence, pragmatism and stability. These are, important qualities in a political leader. 

In the current international political environment, Canada needs a government capable of navigating economic uncertainty. However, I do not believe that competent management is enough to warrant a compelling liberal political identity. Mark Carney is, in large, a centrist. 

There is an innate difference between governing responsibly with compromise as one of your guiding values and allowing that pragmatism to become the soul of your whole entire political platform. A political party should stand for more than being a slightly more accommodating alternative to its conservative opposition. Voters of the left, especially those who are young and looking for hope-inducing change, want to see ambition. And that is hard to find in our current leadership.

The problem with this kind of centre-left leadership is that it is noticeably more concerned with determining what voters will tolerate than establishing what society actually needs. Rather than asking what inequalities should be addressed or what rights should be expanded, politicians increasingly seem preoccupied with what policies might alienate moderate voters. 

Any progressive or ambitious political proposal is dubbed an electoral liability!

For another illustrative example, look no further than our neighbours to the South. Kamala Harris’s unsuccessful 2024 presidential campaign is yet another instance. Having served as Joe Biden's Vice President, Harris struggled to establish herself as something meaningfully different from the administration she was attempting to succeed. 

When asked whether she would have done anything differently from Biden, she famously struggled to identify points of blatant disagreement. 

American voters were already clearly and loudly expressing dissatisfaction with the direction of their country, and the Democratic Party offered a candidate who appeared reluctant to distance herself from the same administration that was being reevaluated via election. 

For example, in reference to the Israel-Palestine conflict, Harris expressed concern about Palestinian civilian suffering and called for a ceasefire, but she maintained the Biden administration's position on continuing military support for Israel. 

For many progressive voters, this was a clear exemplification of the disconnect between Democratic rhetoric about human rights and the administration’s foreign policy. 

My point here is not that a different position on Palestine would have won Kamala Harris the election, but that her campaign as a whole demonstrated a broader problem. When the public is already dissatisfied with the status quo, it is difficult to inspire voters when a candidate is seemingly not departing from those norms. 

A political party cannot ask its supporters to vote for the lesser of two evils and simultaneously expect them to remain hopeful and enthusiastic for its vision of the future. 

In rebuttal to the political norm of the supposed necessity of moderation can be found in the Big Apple! 

Zohran Mamdani is the current mayor of New York City, and he is an openly democratic socialist. He built his mayoral campaign around policies that much of the Democratic establishment might consider politically risky: universal childcare, free public transportation, affordable housing and higher taxes for the extremely wealthy. 

He did not disguise his political ideology, or water it down, or pander to those who disagreed with his core values. He did not wear the mask of a moderate. He offered a distinctly different vision for what a government should accomplish for their people, and he won. 

Of course, democratic socialism is not universally popular, but this campaign and subsequent election challenge the idea that progressive politicians must leave behind ambitious or “radical” policy proposals to attract voters. I don’t believe that voters are tired of progressive politics; I believe that they are tired of cyclical and unchanging politics. I believe that they are tired of feeling as though their vote, oftentimes, makes little difference in their lives.

The political left seems preoccupied with what the political right will tolerate. Policies that would, for example, meaningfully redistribute wealth or legitimately challenge inequality are frequently dismissed as unrealistic, while the status quo remains a sort of natural limit of political possibility. This is contributing to the ideological erosion of the left. What distinguishes Democrats, leftists and liberals from their opponents aside from the “lesser of two evils” mindset? 

A political movement cannot repeatedly compromise its principles without eventually completely compromising its identity. 

This article is a part of our Opinions section and does not necessarily reflect the views of the Gauntlet editorial board.

FEATURED

Dinged-Up Dinos

Dinged-Up Dinos

Injured Dinos learning to deliver early.

—
What the time zone changes mean for you

What the time zone changes mean for you

The province’s abandonment of standard time beginning this month, opting for permanent daylight time, raising concerns about students’ wellbeing as the winter months approach.

—
Calgary’s monthly matchup: November edition

Calgary’s monthly matchup: November edition

From Dinos action to hosting the CPL championship to community runs, November is full of athletic activities for all.

—
Alberta’s Bill 38 calls for “common sense on campus”

Alberta’s Bill 38 calls for “common sense on campus”

Bill 38 draws ire from student leaders for changes to post-secondary education in Alberta.

—

Arts & Culture

Campus News

City News

Features

News

Opinions

Research

Sports